Opened by Yoni Amir and Daniel Maislin of Falafel Yoni fame, Pizza Toni’s New York-style pizza is a no-nonsense homage to a classic American slice. The place serves up the essentials: cheese, marinara, margherita, and pepperoni, plus the standout “grandma” square slice—a rustic, crisp-bottomed slice that captures everything good about NYC’s pizza parlours.

Their style nods to Brooklyn with big bay windows, warm wood panelling, and a touch of bright orange that gives the space an inviting feel. Designed by Menard Dworkind, it’s intentionally laid-back but aesthetically tight. Yoni trained with seasoned pizzaiolos in LA and Villeray to make sure they got it right, and it shows. A quick slice and a soda here are as close as Montreal gets to a genuine NYC pizza experience—minus the subway fare.